©2017 by Ice Cream Cottage

BEST

ICE CREAM
ON LONG ISLAND

- Newsday -

About Us

Making Super 
        Premium Ice Cream

The Ice Cream Cottage opened its doors March of 1990 and is located on Montauk Highway in historic Mastic, New York on Long Island. Since then, the Ice Cream Cottage has won multiple awards.

The summer of 2016, the Ice Cream Cottage won by popular vote the coveted Best Ice-Cream Cone on Long Island award in Newsday. In 2012, the Ice Cream Cottage's world famous Chocolate Overdose was voted the Best Chocolate Ice Cream! 

The Ice Cream Cottage's interior harkens back to a simpler time yet, reflects the hip sensibilities of the up and coming area. The historic Mastic peninsula has long been Long Island's best kept secret—but not for long—with the Ice Cream Cottage bringing crowds to taste the Best Ice Cream on Long Island!

1

Stephan Linton

“The best ice cream in New York! Very small and personal space and not to mention their amazingly friendly staff”

2

Frank Ferrara

“The best... worth the wait from anywhere... heaven in a cone!”

Miguel Estella

3

“1st time ever going here and it was the best BEST ice cream I've ever had! Better then some famous known ice cream brands and the people that worked there were very helpful and friendly. Definitely will be going back!!!!”

Our Flavors

ANY FLAVORS MADE TO YOUR ORDER

We make

WHOLESALE TUBS and novelties

 for RESTAURANT AND FARMS!

Our 35 years experienced specialist will be happy to assist you

call us to 631-395-3580

Apple Cinnamon

Banana Nut Crunch

Bartman

Black Forest

Blackberry

Blueberry  Italian Ice

Brownie Delight

Butter Pecan

Canoli Cream

Cappucinno Chip

Cherry Italian ICe

Cherry Vanilla 

Cheesecake 

Classic Chocolate 

Chocolate Overdose 
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

Coconut 
Coffee 
Cookies & Cream 
Cookie Dough Chunk

Cotton Candy 

 Fresh Banana

Jelly Ring Fudge 

Lemon Italian Ice

Maple Walnut

Maraschino Cherry 

Mastic Mash 

 Mint Chocolate Chip

Mint Cookies & Cream 

Mom’s Cake Batter 

Moose Tracks 

Orange Sherbet 

Peanut Butter & Jelly 

Peanut Butter Fudge 

Pistachio Nut 

Sicilian Pistachio

Pralines & Cream

RAinbow cookie

Reese's Delight 

Rocky Road 

Rum Raisin 

salted Caramel

S'mores 

Snicker 

Strawberry

Strawberry Cheesecake

Vanilla Bean

Vanilla Chip 

Vanilla Fudge

Bellport Bash

Blue Raspberry

Bubble Gum

Cantaloupe

Cake Crunch

Chocolate Coconut 

Chocolate Covered

Banana Chocolate Covered Cherry Chocolate Almond Macaroon

Chocolate Raspberry 

Egg Nog

Garlic 

Hot Habenaro Chilli Pepper 

Lemon 

Mango 
Mastic Beach Berry 

Milky Way

Orange Creamy 

Pina Colada 

Pineapple 

Pumpkin

Purple Cow 
Raspberry 
Strawberry Daiquiri 
Strawberry Kiwi 
Tangerine 
Tara’s Toffee 
Watermelon

Customized Cakes

just for you!

Ice Cream Cakes

Have any cake decorated and custom made!
Choose any flavor, with your favorite picture
right on the cake!

Glory Memolo - Customer

“Yummy ice cream in the world!

We drove 25 minutes

just to get this addicting ice cream.”

 

Tuesdays

Buy 1 get 1 FREE

SOFT  SERVE SUNDAE

Buy 1 get 1

50%

ICE CREAM COTTAGE

Any

saucers

Offer expires on Dec 31, 2019

$1 OFF

Mini Sundae Box

ICE CREAM COTTAGE

Offer expires on Dec 31, 2019

Buy 1 get 1 for 1.00

Offer expires on Dec 31, 2019

Soft Serve

Sundae

You get

$2 OFF

any size 

Cake

Offer expires on Dec 31, 2019

 Print out these coupons or bring them in on your laptop, tablet or smartphone. 

Cannot be combined with ANY OTHER OFFERS. 

ICE CREAM COTTAGE

ICE CREAM COTTAGE